Voter Guide
2024 Primary Election Voter Guide
All candidates listed below are recommendations, with exception for our 2 currently endorsed candidates: Dr. Flojaune Cofer and Katie Valenzuela who we are excited about and actively campaigning for!
This guide:
Highlights endorsements from organizations and allies who are progressive groups and leaders in Sacramento that are actively working to make our county a better place for everyone.
Is intended to be used as a tool to show some progressive candidates running for office in 2024 that we recommend supporting. Our recommended candidates (or decisions to not recommend candidates for a race) are in magenta.
Does not include all races and measures on the March 2024 Election ballot, nor does it necessarily include all candidates running for a particular race. We did not have the capacity to cover all candidates and races for this election.
Check out other voter guides that covered additional races! We listed a few here, but this list is not comprehensive, nor do we necessarily agree with all the endorsements and recommendations in these guides.
Contents:
The following table of contents includes links to the sections below. Each race / decision has a header with a recommended decision, and a dropdown for more context or explanation.
Sacramento County Races
Sacramento County Board of Supervisors
The Board of Supervisors is the governing body of Sacramento County. The Board adopts local policy, appoints officials, creates programs, and controls the County budget. Members of the Board also represent the County on intergovernmental agencies, like Water Districts.
The Board has five members elected to serve four-year terms. In 2024, two members will be elected to the Board for Districts 3 and 4. Rich Desmond, who is currently in his first term representing District 3 on the Board of Supervisors since 2021, is running for re-election unopposed. Sue Frost, who has been representing District 4 on the Board of Supervisors since 2017, is not running for re-election and leaving an open, contested seat.
As the highest authority in the County, the Board of Supervisors is a key race for many progressive issues. The Board funds the Sacramento Sheriff’s Department, distributes state funds for housing, and manages our public health department. This race is particularly important for Sacramento residents who live outside of city limits, as it is their primary form of local government.
District 3 - No confidence, write in #NoNewJail
Incumbent candidate Rich Desmond does not deserve your vote. With a career in law enforcement as a former Chief of California Highway Patrol, he unsurprisingly supports policies that are violent and disinvest in our communities. Desmond’s support for a jail expansion effort that would cost Sacramentans almost $1 billion for a mental health jail, that still fails to comply with a legally binding consent decree Sacramento County is obligated to meet, is disqualifying. Truly disappointing that at a time when so many local candidates are running for statewide office, this critically important role directly responsible for overseeing all of Sacramento County is going unopposed.
Key endorsements to consider:
Organizations: Planned Parenthood Advocates Mar Monte, California Nurses Association, National Union of Healthcare Workers, California Working Families Party, Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment (ACCE) Action, SEIU Local 1021, SEIU Local 2015, Sacramento Central Labor Council (AFL CIO), Los Rios College Federation of Teachers, Democratic Party of Sacramento County, Able Dems, CA Democratic Renters Council, Sacramento County Latino Democratic Club, Folsom Area Democratic Club, Wellstone Progressive Democrats, Women Democrats of Sacramento County, Town & Country Democratic Club, Sacramento County Young Democrats, American River Democrats
Elected Officials: Porsche Middleton (Citrus Heights City Councilmember), Kara Lofthouse (Folsom Cordova School Board Member)
Learn more about the candidates in this race:
Sacramento County Superior Court
In California, superior court judges oversee trials for all criminal and civil cases.
Options
Noel Andrew Calvillo | calvilloforjudge.com
Current occupation: Administrative Law Judge
Candidate summary: "...will not accept endorsements or donations from special interest groups, law enforcement, or lawyers, including prosecutors and defense attorneys"
Key endorsements to consider:
Organizations: Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen
Elected Officials: Sacramento County Supervisors Phil Serna and Don Nottoli (former)
Amy Holliday | hollidayforjudge.com
Current occupation: Deputy District Attorney
Candidate summary: Supported by all the worst actors in Sacramento
Key endorsements to consider:
Organizations: Sacramento County Deputy Sheriffs' Association, Sacramento County Police Officers' Association, Sacramento County Police Chiefs, Elk Grove Police Officers Association, Sacramento County Law Enforcement Managers' Association,
Elected Officials: Sacramento County District Attorney Thien Ho and Anne Marie Schubert (former), Sacramento County Sheriff Jim Cooper and Scott Jones (former),
Other superior court judges: Sacramento Superior Court judges Maryanne Gilliard, Steve White, Kevin McCormick, Michael Sweet, Curtis Fiorini, Tami Bogert, Donald Currier, Shauna Franklin, James McFetridge, Patrick Marlette, Ernest Sawtelle, Matthew Gary, Delbert Oros, James Arguelles, Laurel White and retired judges Michael Savage, Marjorie Keller, Paul Seave, Cheryl Meegan, Eugene Balonon, Greta Fall, Placer Superior Court judge Garen Horst and retired judge Mark Curry, Contra Costa Superior Court judge MaryAnn O'Malley and retired judge Dan O'Malley
Bobby P Luna | lunaforjudge.com
Current occupation: Adjunct Professor and Attorney
Candidate summary: Served in the United States Air Force, supported by private law practices
Sacramento County Democratic Party Central Committee
If you are a registered Democrat in Sacramento County, you have an opportunity to vote for the following progressive candidates to have power in shaping the local Democratic Party. This “slate” is a group of candidates who are all running together. We are just deferring to their self-identification and don’t closely follow the internal workings of the Democratic Party. In districts where the "progressive power slate" did not recommend 6 candidates, if there are candidates we were familiar enough to recommend we added them in magenta text.
Central Committee - Progressive Power Slate
District 1
Andrés Ramos
David Lee Mandel
Mohammad “Mo” Kashmiri
Shirley Toy
Fatima Malik
Tamika L’Ecluse
District 2
Justin “J.D.” Garcia
District 3
John D. Kincaid
Rae Ellen Vander Werf
District 4
Chris Yatooma
District 5
Monica Madrid
Yassar Dahbour
Lee “Marsha” Miller
Randa Allathkani
City Races
Sacramento City Mayor and Council
Sacramento City Council is a nine-member mayor-council system of government, composed of a mayor and eight councilmembers (one per district). Each council member is elected by their respective district to serve four-year terms. In addition to the mayor, four council district representatives will be elected to Sacramento City Council this election representing Districts 2, 4, 6, and 8.
Current Role: Epidemiologist, Senior Policy Director at Public Health Advocates
Key endorsements to consider:
Organizations: Sunrise Movement Sacramento
Elected Officials: Sacramento City Councilmembers Katie Valenzuela and Mai Vang
Flojaune Cofer 2024 Candidate Questionnaire - submitted 10-26-23.pdf
Dr. Flo Cofer holding the Mayor accountable - Note: From 2020 role as Measure U Community Advisory Committee Chair
Sunriser speaking in defense of her campaign and attempts to attack her
Current Role: Policy Director at CivicWell
Key endorsements to consider:
Organizations: Democratic Party of Sacramento County, Wellstone Democratic Club, Sacramento Environmental Democrats, Sacramento Central Labor Council AFL-CIO, Los Rios College Federation of Teachers
Elected Officials: Sacramento City Councilmembers Katie Valenzuela and Mai Vang
The district 2 election comes at a time when this district is currently missing a councilmember due to the resignation / ousting of Sean Loloee who had been holding the seat. We are cautiously optimistic about Roger's platform relative to the other candidates in this race.
Current Role: Sacramento City Councilmember (incumbent), Senior Policy Advocate at Central Valley Air Quality Coalition
Key endorsements to consider:
Organizations: Sunrise Movement Sacramento
Katie Valenzuela 2024 Candidate Questionnaire - submitted 8-27-23.pdf
District 6 - No confidence, write in #StopTheSweeps
We recommend voting against incumbent Eric Guerra, a man who we recently had to meet with to temporarily convince not to advance a policy to “ban daytime camping” and criminalize homelessness across the City of Sacramento.
No viable alternative to consider
Current Role: Sacramento City Councilmember (incumbent)
Key endorsements to consider:
Organizations: We had previously endorsed Mai's first campaign for city council in 2020. She did not seek our support for this primary election.
Elected Officials: Sacramento City Councilmember Katie Valenzuela
Sunrise Sacramento Candidate Interview: Mai Vang - Note: From 2020 election
Sacramento City Ballot measures
Measure C - Yes
We have been in contact with local voters who have received calls from out-of-city real estate interests in opposition of Measure C. To us, this is a reason to support Measure C.
Measure C would correct an outdated flat business tax rate (last updated in 1991) for businesses operating in the city and raising taxable revenue thresholds (from $10k to $100k) to be more inclusive of protecting small businesses and incorporating built in cost-of-living adjustments. This measure would increase the amount of money raised "for general governmental use" by the City of Sacramento.
TLDR: The business tax system in the City of Sacramento is deeply outdated and this feels like a reasonable if not perfect attempt to refresh it
Folsom City Council
The Folsom City Council has five members, elected at-large (i.e., not to a specific district) by the voters of the City. The terms of council members are four years and remain staggered, with three council members being elected at one election and two council members being elected in the next. The City Council selects a mayor and a vice mayor amongst themselves. Districts 2 and 4 are up for election in 2024.
Candidate Summary: A lifelong Folsom resident with experience working as staff in the California State Senate. Hla is active in the local Muslim community and has supported projects of the Council on Islamic Relations (CAIR) CA's local chapter in Sacramento. We don't know much about her platform but Hla has been vocal in calling for a ceasefire.
District 4 - No confidence
Consider: Gul Khan | khan4folsom.com
The greater Sacramento Muslim Public Affairs Committee recommends Gul Khan on their "Vote Ceasefire Candidates" guide. We cannot recommend a candidate whose platform openly calls for increasing the budget of police departments.
State of CA races
California State Assembly
The eighty members of the California State Assembly are elected to two-year terms. Those representing odd-numbered districts run for office during presidential election years, while those in even-numbered districts run for election in gubernatorial election years. Senators are limited to three terms. The primary role of the State Legislature, which includes members of the State Assembly and State Senate, is to write the laws of the state. The Legislature also drafts the state’s plan for public spending.
District 6 - Multiple worthwhile options
State Assembly District 6 - Sean Frame | seanframe.com
Current Role:
Candidate Summary:
Key endorsements to consider:
Organizations: Sierra Club, Sacramento Environmental Democrats, Wellstone Progressive Democrats of Sacramento, CA Progressive Alliance, Our Revolution, Sacramento Sister Circle, Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment (ACCE, dual endorsing both Sean and opponent Evan Minton)
Elected Officials: Dave Jones (Former CA Insurance Commissioner)
State Assembly District 6 - Paula Villescaz | paulavillescaz.com
Current Role:
Candidate Summary:
Key endorsements to consider:
Organizations:
Elected Officials: Sacramento City Councilmember Katie Valenzuela
State Assembly District 7 - Porsche Middleton | porsche4assembly.com
Candidate Summary:
Key endorsements to consider:
Organizations: Planned Parenthood Advocates Mar Monte, California Faculty Association, SEIU California
Elected Officials: Assemblymember Chris Holden
Statewide propositions and referendums
Proposition 1 - No
This is a false solution that reduces funding for existing mental health treatment, in line with many similar moves and reactionary trends locally and nationally to criminalize homelessness, create mental health jails, etc. This is not necessarily our area of expertise so we are deferring to the summaries by opposing organizations linked below.
Proposition 1 is supported by Governor Newsom’s Ballot Measure Committee and Sacramento County Sheriff Jim Cooper
Proposition 1 is opposed by Project Lets, Disability Rights CA, Mental Health America of CA, We Are Revolutionaries, and other mutual aid, harm reduction, and disability rights focused groups.
☀️ California Oil and Gas Well Regulations Referendum (2024) - “Keep the law”
After a more than decade-long campaign, environmental justice communities won a policy that would establish health and safety buffer distance between sites of fossil fuel production and sensitive sites where people live (learn, play, work, etc) through SB 1137. The deeply invested interests of fossil capital are spending tens of millions of dollars to try to repeal this law through this sham of a referendum process.
Process:
A vote to "keep the law" is to uphold Senate Bill 1137 (SB 1137), which would prohibit new oil and gas wells within 3,200 feet of homes, schools, nursing homes, and hospitals and require companies to adopt health, safety, and environmental requirements.
A vote to "overturn the law" is to repeal Senate Bill 1137 (SB 1137), thus keeping the law from taking effect.
TLDR: Say yes to keep SB 1137, say no to big oil profits and their attempted referendum
Pushing to “keep the law”:
Organizations: Central California Environmental Justice Network, Earthjustice, Sierra Club California, Voices in Solidarity Against Oil in Neighborhoods (VISION), Sunrise Movement CA, 350 Sacramento
Elected Officials/People of Note: Governor Gavin Newsom
Pushing to “overturn the law”:
Organizations: California Independent Petroleum Association (CIPA), E & B Natural Resources Management Corp., Macpherson Oil Company LLC, Sentinel Peak Resources California LLC, Signal Hill Petroleum, Inc., State Building and Construction Trades Council of California
United States Federal Government Races
United States Senate
The one hundred members of the United States Senate are elected to six-year terms. Congress, which is made up of the United States Senate and House of Representatives, makes up the legislative branch of government, is responsible for writing laws, and has various powers that can be used to shape the country or - in theory - hold the other branches of federal government accountable. Each state has only two Senators.
In the 2024 election, California has an election to both fill the seat left open by Diane Feinstein’s death (currently held in interim by Governor Newsom’s appointee Laphonza Butler), and to select the next Senator: TLDR, you have to vote twice, once for each of these elections.
Current Role: Congresswoman in the House of Representatives
Candidate Summary: She has been a consistent beacon standing against war. The only candidate in the race calling for a ceasefire in Palestine. In 2001 she was the only member of Congress to vote against President Bush’s war in Iraq. In 2004 she introduced a resolution in Congress to declare genocide was occurring in Darfur, Sudan. She has taken bold stances opposing status-quo US policies of military interventionism, the war on terror, and sanctions as collective punishment as these policies relate to Iraq, Sudan, Afghanistan, Libya, Haiti, Cuba, Palestine and Israel.
United States House of Representatives
Members of the House of Representatives are elected to two-year terms, considered for re-election every even year. Congress, which is made up of the United States Senate and House of Representatives, makes up the legislative branch of government, is responsible for writing laws, and has various powers that can be used to shape the country or - in theory - hold the other branches of federal government accountable. Each state has a number of Representatives dependent upon the population size of the state. In California, you only vote on the Representative for the Congressional House District you live in.
Representative, CA District 6 - Vote against Ami Bera
Ami Bera is an establishment politician and neoliberal democrat who refuses to call for a ceasefire, Medicare For All, or a Green New Deal.
Alternatives to consider:
Adam Barajas | adambarajasforcongress.com
We don't know much about Adam but his platform seems promising as an alternative to Ami Bera
Chris Richardson | rcr4congress.us
Green Party candidate
Current Role: Retired volunteer organizer
Candidate Summary: The only candidate in the race calling for a ceasefire in Palestine, having decided last second to run after being ignored for years by incumbent Doris Matsui. David is a longtime activist and in recent decades organizer based in Sacramento, having spent time on fights for the environment and climate, housing, labor, and against war. He has been involved in, participated in the leadership of, or helped establish local efforts including: the Sacramento co-housing community, the Sacramento Community Land Trust, the Sacramento Regional Coalition for Palestinian Rights, and Jewish Voice for Peace Sacramento. He is not new to the struggle against apartheid in Palestine and has long been engaged in advocacy both here in Sacramento, and as someone who once lived in Israel.
Key endorsements to consider:
Organizations: Wellstone Progressive Democrats of Sacramento, Green Party of Sacramento County, Peace and Freedom Party of Sacramento County, California Progressive Alliance
David Mandel 2024 Candidate Questionnaire - submitted 12-20-23.pdf
United States President
President - "Uncommitted"
President - “Uncommitted” | Rashida Tlaib’s write-in call to action
Congressmember Rashida Tlaib is calling on her community to write in “uncommitted” to send a clear message to the Democratic Party and President Biden.
President - Claudia De la Cruz | https://votesocialist2024.com/
Key endorsements to consider:
Organizations: Party for Socialism and Liberation (PSL)
President - Dr. Cornel West | https://www.cornelwest2024.com/
Candidate Summary: Has long stood for civil rights and liberation struggles and against apartheid and militarism.
President - “Ceasefire” | Write-in
People across the country are organically protesting against President Biden by writing in “ceasefire”
Other guides
Various perspectives on who and what to vote for:
Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment (ACCE) Action Statewide Ballot Guide
Sacramento Democrats for Justice in Palestine Ceasefire Candidates Voter Guide
Sacramento Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) Ceasefire Candidates Voter Guide
Showing Up for Racial Justice Sacramento 2024 Primary Election Resource Guide
Nonpartisan educational resources for voters:
General information about races We did not have time to cover
Flood Control Districts
Flood control districts oversee dual goals of protecting rivers and their surrounding ecosystems and implementing plans and preparedness activities to increase our community’s resilience to flooding. This role is crucial in Sacramento, which is more vulnerable to catastrophic flooding than any other major city in the United States except New Orleans. Located at the confluence of the American and Sacramento Rivers, the city has a long history of damaging floods, and climate change is projected to make flooding in our region much worse.
Sacramento continues to rank low in flood preparedness and levee maintenance, putting thousands of residents at risk. Additionally, a recent drought, exacerbated by climate change, negatively affected water reliability in the Sacramento region and left lasting impacts on our rivers. Further, as more people are forced into houselessness in Sacramento, more individuals seek shelter on the banks and levees of the American and Sacramento Rivers. The candidates elected in these roles and the policies they enact will have lasting effects on how prepared our communities are in the face of climate change, how we support our unsheltered population, and how we address our houselessness crisis.
Resource Conservation Districts
Resource Conservation Districts (or RCDs) partner with local communities on a voluntary basis to care for land, water, soil, and other natural resources. RCD boards of directors conduct research relating to the conservation of resources and share that research with their district members. They can charge fees for services they provide, make improvements on public lands to conserve resources, and provide technical assistance to district residents to help minimize soil and other resource degradation.
Fire Protection Districts
Fire Protection Districts provide fire protection and ambulance and rescue services. The Sacramento districts’ elections listed are managed by Sacramento County - note that some districts do overlap with surrounding counties. Elections are held on even years, and terms of office are four-year staggered terms. Some Fire Protection Districts elect their board members at-large (meaning if four positions are available then the top four candidates from that district become board members). Others divide their districts further into divisions and elect one board member per division.
Recreation and Park Districts
Recreation and Park Districts provide recreation programs, local parks, and open spaces. There are 21 districts in Sacramento County; each district is governed by a five-member board with members serving four-year terms. The board is responsible for establishing policies for the operation of the district.
Parks, open spaces, and trails are key to preserving our water and air quality, reducing congestion, and protecting wildlife. Board members’ decisions can either increase or decrease access and opportunities for underrepresented and underserved communities to participate in city programs and services that will impact their physical and mental health. Social equity must be a focus of recreation and park district board members so that public parks and recreation programs are provided on an equitable basis to all community members served by the district.
Water / Irrigation Districts
Water Districts are publicly owned water utilities. They set prices and supply water to their geographic district. The water utilities are governed by five-member boards elected to four-year terms. The boards are the highest authority and approve key decisions like the budget, infrastructure for safe drinking water, and prices for water and sewage bills.
Water is a human right, and as we know from poisonings like the Flint water crisis, how cities manage their water can have devastating impacts on people. Also, it is good to keep tabs on sustainable water use during California’s droughts. These boards are overwhelmingly older, white, and college-educated, so it would be good for a younger and more diverse group of folks to have a say in how water is supplied and how much it costs.
Community College Districts
Community College Districts are governed by a Board of Trustees, similar to other School Districts. The boards are responsible for the educational, physical, and financial decisions of the district, in addition to setting legal policy for the district. The boards also conduct studies and surveys around the district’s progress on equity, justice and inclusion.
Trustees also advocate for financial aid at the federal level, which can significantly impact student outcomes. Being an effective advocate means educating policymakers about the needs of their communities and showing them how community colleges affect lives and economies for the better. Since trustees control the budget for their districts, it’s critical that we elect board members whose values align with our own.